Last updated on

 The Most Comfortable Steel and Composite Toe Safety Boots; Guide of 2019

Safety toe protectors will keep your feet safe by creating a barrier between your toes and any heavy objects that could crush your toes. Let’s find the best steel toe work boots together! 

Quality work shoes are the most important personal protective equipment (PPE) that we use each day. The footing workwear we choose to wear can make or break our feet.

Best steel toe work boots are muddyHaving a safety toe, made from steel or composite materials are a must. It’s required by law to even enter construction sites and most other dangerous workplaces.

Knowing which work boots to buy for your individual workplace can sometimes be a difficult situation. That’s why here are we have done all the hard research for you and placed it into easy to read pages.

This has been a proven safety feature of work boots for years. We have put together a great guide to help to choose the best steel toe work boots and best composite work boots.

Most Comfortable Steel Toe boots

Thorogood American heritage steel toe work boot: Rated 9.5/ 10 for comfort!

Thorogood work boots are built safe




Best Composite Toe Work Boots

Timberland PRO Boondock composite work boot: Rated 9/10 for safety!

Timberland leather, waterproof work shoe





PictureNameSteel or compositePrice Rating
Cat safety toe work bootCaterpillar Men's Diagnostic Waterproof Steel-Toe Work BootSteel$$$4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)
Timberland safety work bootTimberland PRO Men's Expertise LT Steel-Toe Work BootSteel$$4.1 out of 5 stars (4.1 / 5)
safety toe work bootsSkechers for Work Men's 77015 Vostok Slip Resistant Work Boot-Composite$$4.3 out of 5 stars (4.3 / 5)
Thorogood  safety toe work bootThorogood Men's Composite Safety Toe Work BootCompostite$$$4.1 out of 5 stars (4.1 / 5)
Cat safety toe work bootCaterpillar Men's Revolver Pull-On Steel-Toe BootSteel$4.3 out of 5 stars (4.3 / 5)

Steel Toes

Steel toe work boots have been around for years keeping your feet protected from heavy machinery, equipment and material. It’s one of the main features we come to expect from heavy duty work boots.

What are the other options aside from steel toe work boots?

Composite safety toe boot protectors

Composite safety toesComposite toes refer to toe protectors that don’t contain any metal. They usually consist of carbon fibre,
high-grade plastics and ultra-strong rubber.

There is a new material that is a very strong and light weight material used to create work boots. This type of work boot toe protector is becoming very popular and has some different features to the steel toe. To know what type of work boot is best suited to you-you need to understand the pros and cons of each material.

What are these features? Let’s take a look at the two types of toe protectors and compare

 Composite toesSteel toes
Pros-Light weight

- Electrical resistant

- Will not set off metal detectors

-Much better insulating properties

- Impenetrable

- Will not shatter

Cons- Usually costs more

- Not as heavy duty as metal caps
- Much more weight

- Can freeze in extreme weather

- Will set off metal detextor alarms

Steel toes boots are best suited for;

  • Workers that work around very heavy machinery and equipment
  •  Anyone who works under high scaffold or cranes ( best protection from falling objects )
  •  Some construction sites have a requirement that steel toe work boots are only used
  • If you are exposed to dangerous rubble and want to be safe from material that is known to pounce work boots = sharp steel and glass

  Composite toes boots are best suited for;

  • If your daily job requires you to walk through metal detectors each day then composite toes are for you. Composite toes will not set off the metal detectors
  • Composite toes are perfect for jobs in security areas such as airports, goals and banks
  • If you are working in extremely cold climates composite toes are proven to insulate a lot better
  •  Do you need to be light on your feet? If so composite boots will be a lot lighter if you are wanting  to shed some weight from your boots. What is best is to find the best work boots for standing all day.

Which material performs best as a toe protector?

Steel toes and composite toes are both approved by OHSA. so they have both been thoroughly tested.steel safety toes

Both materials will keep your feet from being crushed. Depending on your work situation you will now have the best information to make the choice.

Can steel toes break and under a heavy load and cut off your toes?

This has been a common myth around building sites for years. We have all heard it.

A long story short is that this is a myth. Thanks to our friends at myth busters they have proven this to be a myth. They like the OHSA have proven that your feet are much safer in a pair of steel toe work boots.

“The steel toe will always prove to be the strongest part of the work boot”

Jamie from “ myth busters”


Who makes the best steel toe work boots?

We have had a good look through all the big brands selling on and  we have set out a page just to review the best work boots brands. The page will help you decide on which boot brand it the best suit for your workplace.

Best Steel toe work boots for Men

Thorogood American heritage safety toe work boot: Best steel toe work boot for men

4.7 out of 5 stars (4.7 / 5)

The most stylish boot on the list, the Thorogood American Heritage is quality crafted of tobacco-
tanned leather with a white cotton lining. They might go up a bit high on the leg for sThorogood work boots are built safe with a solid safety toe ome, but personally, I think they look awesome.

Surprisingly, for such a high boot, they are also nice and breathable, which is the reason they’re such a favorable choice for working in the sun. Thanks to both a shock absorbent sole and an additional insert, they are also ridiculously comfortable, with absolutely no break in period. The arch support is absolutely perfect. Compared to most safety toe boots they are lighter and last longer which makes them the best for hard work, every day. Well-crafted of good thick leather, real cow-hide, this is a tough, rugged, dependable boot with true grip traction to keep you safe. They stand up well to rough job site conditions such as rusty metal, concrete, sand, muck, water, oily surfaces.

The Heritage line also happens to be one of the best steel toe work boots for men on And it’s not surprising. This boot outperforms and outlasts pretty much all other work boots.


Caterpillar second shift safety toe boot: Most Comfortable Steel Toe Boots for standing all day

4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

The first thing about these boots that grabs your attention is the high quality of the leather. The professional craftsmanship is apparent from the get-go and you get the immediate impression that they’re built to last.

Safe and comfy work boot by CAT

Once I made it through the break-in period, I found them exceptionally comfortable. The sole was fashioned with ergonomics in mind. How about the steel toe shields your foot against crushing objects, bulky equipment, or heavy material that could fall on it. These are the most comfortable steel toe boots for standing all day on the job.

In terms of style, they also score highly. If you’re looking for something that you can wear to work, this is it. I especially like the fact that they come in a wide range of colors. It’s nearly impossible to find a fine quality work boot that is comfortable all through the day and is also trendy. It’s especially hard to find all three qualities in steel toe boots. But these boots have it all—almost.

I have to say, there are two things I don’t like about these boots, the break-in period and their tendency for getting wet.

The first two weeks of wear are uncomfortable, to say the least. There is a good deal of soreness involved you will have to break these boots in. This is something that has been echoed in multiple customer reviews. These boots are also not waterproof and seem to get wet from just the slightest bit of rain.


Keen Utility Tacoma Work Boot: Best composite toe boots

4.4 out of 5 stars (4.4 / 5)


Keen safety toe work bootOne gripe that often plagues steel safety toe boots is that they are heavy. Work boots are heavy enough as is without adding the additional weight of steel to them. Keen took on this challenge and the result is their Tacoma boot, which should solve this problem.

The solution is they don’t envelop a full fifth of the boot in steel. Instead, they just cover the actual toe area for less weight, yet full protection.

Keen like to add a bit of yellow to their work boots to give them a unique touch of style. Also, the heavy-duty construction and the craftsmanship that has gone into these boots are superb. Everything about these boots is solid

— including the stitching. I’ve also read quite a few reviews praising their durability. But not only are they long lasting you’ll be as pleased with these boots after wearing them day after day as much as you were the very day you bought them.

In addition, they are waterproof and chemical resistant, yet breathable. They deliver a high level of comfort to your legs and feet. The traction on them is fantastic and they are slip resistant on wet and oily work floors.



Timberland Pro Pitboss Work Boot: Best overall Steel Toe Work Boot

4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)

This Timberland Pro boot is an Amazon bestseller. Presenting the mutual benefits of value and Timberland safety toe work boot
comfort. These budget-conscious boots perform like they’re worth a million bucks. This steel toe work boot holds its own against mud, dirt, clay, and concrete.

Also the leather shields against punctures from nails, lumber, and other abrasive objects. So your feet won’t get crushed or cut. Slip and oil resistance is provided by traction grip soles and these boots are both waterproof and equipped with electrical hazard protection.

Comfort levels are further enhanced by an open-cell polyurethane footbed which retains most of its cushioning year after year. And also delivers high levels of breathability, moisture transport, and an anti-microbial function so your foot is cooler, drier, and healthier. It also has a removable sock insert offering maximum support.

Available in your choice of four different colors, they have a popular low-key style that’s perfect for the job site of factory warehouse. The customers rave about these being the best steel toe work boots they have used. And these are a top rated work boot.

These boots have been constructed using the-the Goodyear welt construction method that you know you can trust to last. It’s not uncommon for these boots to last up to 3 years.  How good is that!!

These boots are going to mold to your feet instantly so you don’t need to worry about any nasty breaking period. that is a great feature! This is one of the best steel toe work boots on the market!

Timberland has an impressive 30 day no questions asked return policy


Click here see the the best waterproof work boots!